Thanks for submitting the revised version of your paper and for your very thorough response to the reviewers. I am happy that you have addressed the points raised by the reviewers, and given a good explanation as to why you have not necesarily implemented all of their ideas in this paper. I am requesting some very minor revisions to improve the clarity of the paper, but expect that once these are done it will be suitable for publication. (Please view and go through the list of comments in the attached pdf, as some of the minor corrections might be difficult to spot in the main text.)

Thanks for making these minor edits to the paper, which have helped to explain the importance of the work. I'm happy to recommend that your paper is now published. I think that it is a useful contribution to meauring bedload in sandy-gravel rivers.

Best wishes,
Rebecca

Dear Jules le Guern and colleagues,
Thank you for working with AE Rebecca Hodge and her referees during the review and revision of your manuscript. I am happy to follow her advice and approve publication of the manuscript in its present form.
Your manuscript will now be prepared for print by the Copernicus publishers. Your prompt response to their queries and instructions will help to speed up the last steps.
Thank you for submitting your work to ESurf. I very much look forward to seing the final product and trust that your paper will receive good attention from the expert community.
Best wishes,
Niels Hovius